What a Detroit Merchant Actually Pays to Accept a Card: Credit Card Processing Fees, Explained With Real Numbers
What a Detroit Merchant Actually Pays to Accept a Card: Credit Card Processing Fees, Explained With Real Numbers

On a $100 card sale, a typical small merchant pays roughly $3.20 in processing: 2.9% plus 30 cents. At our proposed 1.5% base network fee, the same sale would cost about $1.50. Both figures are illustrative estimates, and the gap is why most owners start looking for a different way to get paid.
Cost is only half of the decision. The other half is who gets approved at all, and what that process feels like from the owner's side of the table. That is merchant underwriting. First Round does not lend money, but a payment network still makes a judgement when it considers a business for onboarding, and that judgement decides whether an owner can accept payments through us. It should be careful, clear, and proportionate.
Where the money actually goes
A card payment is split before it ever reaches your account. Three parties take a cut, and only one of them is the company you signed up with.
The first is interchange, the portion that goes to the bank that issued the customer's card. It is generally the largest single component of the total, and it varies by card type and by how the payment is taken. The second is the network assessment, which goes to the card network. The third is your processor's markup, which is the part a provider actually controls and the part worth negotiating.
That split explains a frustration many owners have felt. When a processor quotes you "interchange plus" pricing, they are showing you their markup on top of a cost they do not set. When a processor quotes a flat rate, they are folding all three into one number and keeping the difference. Neither is dishonest. But only one of them tells you what you are actually paying for.

Why a small ticket costs so much more than a large one
The percentage is only half the story. The fixed fee is the half that hurts a coffee shop, a food truck, or anyone selling small items all day.
At 2.9% plus 30 cents, a $5 sale costs $0.445. That is 8.9% of the sale. The 30 cents is a fixed charge, so it does not shrink when the ticket does. A $100 sale under the same terms costs $3.20, or 3.2%. Same rate, very different economics.
| Ticket size | Typical card at 2.9% + $0.30 | At a 1.5% fee | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $5 | $0.45 (8.9% of the sale) | $0.08 | $0.37 |
| $20 | $0.88 (4.4%) | $0.30 | $0.58 |
| $100 | $3.20 (3.2%) | $1.50 | $1.70 |
| $500 | $14.80 (3.0%) | $7.50 | $7.30 |
These are illustrative estimates calculated from the rates shown, not quotes. Your cost depends on your own terms and transaction mix.
What that gap looks like over a month
Take a cafe doing 3,000 tickets a month at an $8 average, or $24,000 in card sales. That mix matters, because the fixed fee is charged 3,000 times.
At 2.9% plus 30 cents, that month costs $696 in percentage fees plus $900 in fixed fees, or $1,596. That is an effective rate of about 6.65%, well above the 2.9% the owner might have been quoted. At a 1.5% fee, the same month costs $360.
The gap is $1,236 for the month, or roughly $14,832 over a year, on illustrative rates. For an independent business, that is a piece of equipment, a hire, or a cushion through a slow January. It is also exactly the kind of number a merchant discovers only after reading a statement closely, which is the argument for reading it closely.
Why the same revenue can mean two different things
Cost is the easier half of this conversation. The harder half is who gets approved in the first place, and what that process feels like from the owner's side.
Evaluating a business is not the same as scoring a form. It means understanding the business model and the person running it, which is harder than it sounds when an application arrives as a set of numbers.
Consider two businesses with the same reported revenue. One is a barbershop that has served the same Detroit block for ten years. The other is a new online brand. The revenue figure alone does not tell you how durable either business is, how it reaches customers, or what might happen when a difficult month comes along.
That does not mean one business is automatically a better risk. It means the number needs context. The questions worth asking depend on how the business operates, where its sales come from, and what evidence supports its account of those sales. A small business is not a spreadsheet, and a fair review should look at both the operating model and the documentation behind it.
What a fair onboarding process should look like
Onboarding needs discipline. Know what stage you are at, what information is needed, and what has to be true before you move forward. A process that skips those steps wastes the owner's time and produces a decision nobody can explain.

A business owner should know what information is being requested and why. For First Round, onboarding includes KYC/AML checks and business verification, or KYB. That means asking for real documents to support verification, rather than treating a checkbox as enough.
Most verifications clear in about two business days. That is an expected timeframe, not a guarantee of approval or a promise that every application will take the same amount of time. A business may need to provide more information, and the review may take longer.
Clear sequencing helps on both sides. The merchant knows what to provide. The network can assess the application against the information it actually needs.
Due diligence, in plain terms
Due diligence is the work of checking what is true before you make a decision. In payments the stakes are lower than in an acquisition, but the discipline is the same: verify the claim, look for the material concern early, and say what you found.
If something in an application does not support approval, it is better to identify and explain that early than to leave an owner waiting for a surprise at the end.

For a merchant, an unclear decision has a real cost. It can mean lost time, delayed plans, and uncertainty about how to accept payments. A fair process cannot promise approval, but it can aim to make the requirements and next steps understandable.
That is the standard we want merchant onboarding to meet: explain what is needed, review it, and give a direct answer. If we cannot approve a business, we should say so plainly.
Where the analogy breaks
This is the most important limit to the comparison. A private equity deal is a transaction between sophisticated parties who expect a return. A neighborhood store is somebody’s livelihood and part of the economic life of a block.
The tools can transfer. The attitude does not.
A merchant should not be treated as an asset to optimize. A risk review should help determine whether a business can participate responsibly in a payment network. It should not reduce the owner to a score or assume that a small operation deserves less explanation than a large one.
That distinction matters in Detroit, where independent businesses serve customers, employ people, and anchor neighborhoods. A barbershop, food truck, or boutique should get a review that takes its actual operating model seriously.
What this changes in practice at First Round
For us, the practical implications are modest and concrete:
- Start with the business. A risk conversation should begin by understanding what the merchant does and how it earns revenue, before discussing pricing.
- Ask for what matters. Verification questions should relate to the business and the review, not add paperwork without a clear purpose.
- Be honest about timing. Most KYC/AML and KYB verifications clear in about two business days, but timing can vary and approval is not guaranteed.
- Explain the payment model. First Round’s network is designed for settlement in about three seconds, compared with two to three business days for card networks. Payments are final once settled, with zero chargebacks. That removes a category of exposure merchants face on card rails, but it also means payment finality should be clearly understood.
- Keep custody clear. First Round is non-custodial by architecture. Merchants hold their own keys, and First Round never takes custody of their funds.
Our proposed base network fee is 1.5%. Actual terms and availability are confirmed with merchants individually. The operating details matter, but so does how we assess the businesses that may use the network.
The questions owners actually ask
What percentage do payment processors take?
It depends on the structure. Flat-rate pricing commonly sits near 2.9% plus a fixed amount per transaction, while interchange-plus pricing separates the bank and network costs from the processor's markup. The percentage you were quoted is rarely the rate you pay once the fixed fee and additional charges are counted.
Why is my effective rate higher than the rate I signed up for?
Usually the fixed per-transaction fee on small tickets, plus charges that are not part of the headline rate at all, such as monthly fees, equipment rental, statement fees and dispute fees. Divide total fees by total card sales for a month and compare that number with the rate you were quoted.
Is a lower percentage always cheaper?
No. A low percentage with a high fixed fee can cost more than a slightly higher percentage with none, especially for businesses selling small amounts frequently. Model it on your own average ticket.
What does final settlement mean for chargebacks?
On First Round's network, payments are final once settled, so the card-dispute process does not apply. That is a real difference from card rails, but it moves responsibility rather than removing it: clear refund and cancellation terms matter more, not less, when a payment cannot be reversed by a bank.
Why our founder spent November on coursework
After the numbers, a note on where this is coming from.

In November 2026, First Round founder and CEO Khari Allen completed four job simulations through Forage: Goldman Sachs Risk, Bank of America Investment Banking, and Vista Equity Partners' Understanding the Deal Lifecycle and Demystifying Private Equity. Between them they covered risk identification and mitigation, financial modeling and company analysis, private equity deal mechanics, and due diligence.
Forage is the issuer. Goldman Sachs, Bank of America and Vista Equity Partners did not employ or endorse him, and these are job simulations rather than certifications, internships or professional designations. They are not part of First Round's compliance program and do not qualify anyone for a compliance, licensing or risk role.
What they are is one founder's effort to understand how the other side of a table thinks, so that our questions are better aimed and our answers are plainer. That is the standard we want merchant onboarding to meet, and the coursework is a footnote to it, not the headline.
If you want to check your own numbers before we talk, take last month's statement, add up every line you were charged, and divide by your card sales. Bring that number to the conversation and the discussion gets concrete fast.
Independent Detroit businesses can talk with our merchant team at support@firstroundcoin.com.